SAP S/4 HANA - ERS High Availability Cluster

milind_dhoke · November 28, 2019, 6:24pm

Hi Folks,

I did the ERS Cluster configuration SAP S/4 Hana as stated in below link.

https://documentation.suse.com/sbp/all/html/SAP_S4HA10_SetupGuide-SLE15/index.html

The HAWK interface shows all the configured resources as green, but on doing manual fencing of the nodes the cluster resources does not move from one node to another.

Below is the crm config :

node 1: CHHANA-PRAP1
node 2: CHHANAERS1 \
attributes standby=off maintenance=off
primitive admin-ip IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.42 \
op monitor interval=10 timeout=20 \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.43 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.44 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ASCS00_sapen2as START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ASCS00_CHHANAAP" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false \
meta resource-stickiness=5000 maintenance=false target-role=Started
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ERS10_sapen2er START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ERS10_CHHANAERS" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false IS_ERS=true
primitive stonith-sbd stonith:external/sbd \
params pcmk_delay_max=30s \
meta maintenance=false
group grp_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 \
meta resource-stickiness=3000
group grp_S4P_ERS10 rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10
location cli-ban-admin-ip-on-CHHANAERS1 admin-ip role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ASCS00-on-CHHANAERS1 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ERS10-on-CHHANA-PRAP1 grp_S4P_ERS10 role=Started -inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-ban-stonith-sbd-on-CHHANAERS1 stonith-sbd role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-prefer-admin-ip admin-ip role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-grp_S4P_ASCS00 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-stonith-sbd stonith-sbd role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
colocation col_sap_S4P_no_both -5000: grp_S4P_ERS10 grp_S4P_ASCS00
order ord_sap_S4P_first_start_ascs Optional: rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00:start rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10:stop symmetrical=false
property cib-bootstrap-options: \
have-watchdog=true \
dc-version=“2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9-3.3.1-2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9” \
cluster-infrastructure=corosync \
cluster-name=hacluster \
stonith-enabled=true \
placement-strategy=balanced \
maintenance-mode=false
rsc_defaults rsc-options: \
resource-stickiness=1 \
migration-threshold=3
op_defaults op-options: \
timeout=600 \
record-pending=true

Kindly let me know if you find any inconsistencies with the configuration.

Rich · December 2, 2019, 6:13pm

[QUOTE=milind_dhoke;58968]Hi Folks,

I did the ERS Cluster configuration SAP S/4 Hana as stated in below link.

https://documentation.suse.com/sbp/all/html/SAP_S4HA10_SetupGuide-SLE15/index.html

The HAWK interface shows all the configured resources as green, but on doing manual fencing of the nodes the cluster resources does not move from one node to another.

Below is the crm config :

node 1: CHHANA-PRAP1
node 2: CHHANAERS1 \
attributes standby=off maintenance=off
primitive admin-ip IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.42 \
op monitor interval=10 timeout=20 \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.43 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.44 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ASCS00_sapen2as START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ASCS00_CHHANAAP" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false \
meta resource-stickiness=5000 maintenance=false target-role=Started
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ERS10_sapen2er START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ERS10_CHHANAERS" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false IS_ERS=true
primitive stonith-sbd stonith:external/sbd \
params pcmk_delay_max=30s \
meta maintenance=false
group grp_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 \
meta resource-stickiness=3000
group grp_S4P_ERS10 rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10
location cli-ban-admin-ip-on-CHHANAERS1 admin-ip role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ASCS00-on-CHHANAERS1 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ERS10-on-CHHANA-PRAP1 grp_S4P_ERS10 role=Started -inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-ban-stonith-sbd-on-CHHANAERS1 stonith-sbd role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-prefer-admin-ip admin-ip role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-grp_S4P_ASCS00 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-stonith-sbd stonith-sbd role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
colocation col_sap_S4P_no_both -5000: grp_S4P_ERS10 grp_S4P_ASCS00
order ord_sap_S4P_first_start_ascs Optional: rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00:start rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10:stop symmetrical=false
property cib-bootstrap-options: \
have-watchdog=true \
dc-version=“2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9-3.3.1-2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9” \
cluster-infrastructure=corosync \
cluster-name=hacluster \
stonith-enabled=true \
placement-strategy=balanced \
maintenance-mode=false
rsc_defaults rsc-options: \
resource-stickiness=1 \
migration-threshold=3
op_defaults op-options: \
timeout=600 \
record-pending=true

Kindly let me know if you find any inconsistencies with the configuration.[/QUOTE]

Looks like you have left some manual migration constraints in the cluster configuration.
All of these cli* constraints should be removed /deleted from the cib.

You may use “crm configure edit” or HAWK to remove these constraints. They were all put there by manually moving or migrating resources.

location cli-ban-admin-ip-on-CHHANAERS1 admin-ip role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ASCS00-on-CHHANAERS1 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ERS10-on-CHHANA-PRAP1 grp_S4P_ERS10 role=Started -inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-ban-stonith-sbd-on-CHHANAERS1 stonith-sbd role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-prefer-admin-ip admin-ip role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-grp_S4P_ASCS00 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-stonith-sbd stonith-sbd role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1

sandergemert · December 5, 2019, 6:02pm

Hi

Please check your setting for quorum policy
If not set to ignore and you only run 2 nodes, it will not be acivated on the remaining node

crm configure property no-quorum-policy=ignore

strahil-nikolov-dxc · December 25, 2019, 11:36pm

[QUOTE=milind_dhoke;58968]Hi Folks,

I did the ERS Cluster configuration SAP S/4 Hana as stated in below link.

https://documentation.suse.com/sbp/all/html/SAP_S4HA10_SetupGuide-SLE15/index.html

The HAWK interface shows all the configured resources as green, but on doing manual fencing of the nodes the cluster resources does not move from one node to another.

Below is the crm config :

node 1: CHHANA-PRAP1
node 2: CHHANAERS1 \
attributes standby=off maintenance=off
primitive admin-ip IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.42 \
op monitor interval=10 timeout=20 \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ASCS00" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 Filesystem \
params device=“10.10.119.45:/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10” directory="/usr/sap/S4P/ERS10" fstype=nfs \
op start timeout=60s interval=0 \
op stop timeout=60s interval=0 \
op monitor interval=20s timeout=40s
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.43 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s \
meta target-role=Started maintenance=false
primitive rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 IPaddr2 \
params ip=10.10.119.44 \
op monitor interval=10s timeout=20s
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ASCS00_sapen2as START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ASCS00_CHHANAAP" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false \
meta resource-stickiness=5000 maintenance=false target-role=Started
primitive rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10 SAPInstance \
operations $id=rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10-operations \
op monitor interval=11 timeout=60 \
op_params on_fail=restart \
params InstanceName=S4P_ERS10_sapen2er START_PROFILE="/usr/sap/S4P/SYS/profile/S4P_ERS10_CHHANAERS" AUTOMATIC_RECOVER=false IS_ERS=true
primitive stonith-sbd stonith:external/sbd \
params pcmk_delay_max=30s \
meta maintenance=false
group grp_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_ip_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_fs_S4P_ASCS00 rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00 \
meta resource-stickiness=3000
group grp_S4P_ERS10 rsc_ip_S4P_ERS10 rsc_fs_S4P_ERS10 rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10
location cli-ban-admin-ip-on-CHHANAERS1 admin-ip role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ASCS00-on-CHHANAERS1 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-ban-grp_S4P_ERS10-on-CHHANA-PRAP1 grp_S4P_ERS10 role=Started -inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-ban-stonith-sbd-on-CHHANAERS1 stonith-sbd role=Started -inf: CHHANAERS1
location cli-prefer-admin-ip admin-ip role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-grp_S4P_ASCS00 grp_S4P_ASCS00 role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
location cli-prefer-stonith-sbd stonith-sbd role=Started inf: CHHANA-PRAP1
colocation col_sap_S4P_no_both -5000: grp_S4P_ERS10 grp_S4P_ASCS00
order ord_sap_S4P_first_start_ascs Optional: rsc_sap_S4P_ASCS00:start rsc_sap_S4P_ERS10:stop symmetrical=false
property cib-bootstrap-options: \
have-watchdog=true \
dc-version=“2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9-3.3.1-2.0.1+20190417.13d370ca9” \
cluster-infrastructure=corosync \
cluster-name=hacluster \
stonith-enabled=true \
placement-strategy=balanced \
maintenance-mode=false
rsc_defaults rsc-options: \
resource-stickiness=1 \
migration-threshold=3
op_defaults op-options: \
timeout=600 \
record-pending=true

Kindly let me know if you find any inconsistencies with the configuration.[/QUOTE]

You have too many location constraints caused by migrations (you can identify them by ‘cli-ban’ and ‘cli-prefer’).
Just run 'crm resource unmigrate ’ where TARGET is every resource inthe group and each group in the cluster.

This is a ‘rookie’ mistake to people new to openais & corosync/pacemaker stacks.

strahil-nikolov-dxc · December 25, 2019, 11:38pm

[QUOTE=sandergemert;59006]Hi

Please check your setting for quorum policy
If not set to ignore and you only run 2 nodes, it will not be acivated on the remaining node

crm configure property no-quorum-policy=ignore[/QUOTE]
In recent versions this is a bad recommendation.
ha-cluster-init properly sets the ‘two_node= true’ flag on each member of the cluster which sets the quorum to be artificially set to ‘1’ .

Topic		Replies	Views
Hana and SAP on the same node, 2 Nodes configuration for HA SLES High Availability Extension	2	633	February 4, 2020
SUSE High Availability Extension for SAP HANA SLES High Availability Extension	1	632	July 3, 2020
SAP A(S)CS/ERS HA on SLES - Never worked SLES High Availability Extension	4	476	July 26, 2017
Re: SLES 11 HAE with SAP SLES Configure-Administer	0	177	October 6, 2011
Maintenance mode on cluster did not work SLES High Availability Extension	1	536	April 30, 2018

SAP S/4 HANA - ERS High Availability Cluster

Related topics